MACCA-News: Livestock and Greenhouse Gas Expert Says McCartney Has it Wrong - Tuesday, December 15, 2009    @MACCA-Central.com           
Tue. December 15 2009
To see all the Latest Beatle & MACCA News
click here  
MACCA & Beatle News
MACCA-central.com

Livestock and Greenhouse Gas Expert Says McCartney Has it Wrong
Source: hoosieragtoday.com
Updated: Dec.15,2009 10:04 Bookmark and Share

Discussions at the climate change summit in Copenhagen are aimed at combating global warming. A meat free Monday campaign is one idea that has come up. Former Beatle and vegetarian Paul McCartney says the production of food from farm to fork accounts for 20 to 30 percent of global greenhouse gas emissions and livestock production is responsible for half of these emissions. But University of California-Davis Associate Professor Dr. Frank Mitloehner, an expert on livestock and greenhouse gases, says those numbers are inaccurate.

Mitloehner says, “We’ve just published a paper in a scientific peer-reviewed journal. It’s called Clearing the Air, Livestock’s Contribution to Climate Change, and we have shown that in the United States livestock contributes a total of three percent of the overall carbon volume. Three percent of all greenhouse gases are associated with animal production and another three percent to crop production.”

Mitloehner adds that in undeveloped countries like Ethiopia livestock is causing a higher percentage of greenhouse gases than they would in developed countries like the U.S. and England. The main reason is England and the U.S. are becoming more efficient in raising livestock, where underdeveloped countries haven’t been able to do that yet. “A cow can be twenty to thirty years old over there until she falls over from age. But she is not efficient, and a steer is not efficient either, and a pig is not efficient, and poultry is not efficient. So they should learn from the developed countries how to produce as much meat and animal protein as possible, with as few resources as necessary.”

Mitloehner says global demand for animal protein will double in the next 30 years because of China and India.

 



  view comments Comments (2)

2 people have commented on this story so far. Tell us what you think below.

While I find the whole "climate change" debates to be silly more than anything else, McCartney can say whatever the hell he wants; that doesn`t make him an expert on scientific studies. It`s just another opportunity for McCartney to use his rock legend status to shove his beliefs and opinions (namely vegatarianism) down your throat. McCartney is an entertainer (and a damn good one); but I ain`t givin` up McDonald`s for him. Sorry, Paul.
- Awesoman - Atlanta, GA (FUNsite member)
Posted Posted at 01:47AM Dec. 17th 2009 Click to report an abusive comment[reply]  
Mr. Mitloehner`s assessment makes no sense. For example, ot is incorrect for him to say that his paper has just been published. In fact, publication of his paper preceded publication by Worldwatch in November 2009 of an assessment that at least 51% of human-caused greenhouse gas emissions are attributable to the life cycle and supply chain of livestock products. Macca has been using the older estimate of 20-30%. Mr. Mitloehner uses a suspect figure of 3% for the U.S. alone - whereas greenhouse gas emissions and their effects are transboundary, so no one country should be examined in isolation. However, it makes sense for Mr. Mitloehner to discuss possible growth in demand for meat in China and India. But it makes better sense to do as Macca does, and recommend that demand be reduced rather than increased.
- Worldwatcher - Copenhagen, Denmark (Guest)  click to register
Posted Posted at 01:52AM Dec. 16th 2009 Click to report an abusive comment[reply]  

Add a comment to the topic:
Livestock and Greenhouse Gas Expert Says McCartney Has it Wrong

Please enter your name, city, email and comment below:
  Name:
  Email:Your email address will not be published  
  City/Country:
  Enter your comment:Terms and conditions
  You have  characters left.make text area bigger
    
    
MathGuard security question, please solve:

LT9         C92      
X      5      5   GIB
F8E   5J2   P45      
O G    I    S     NCP
X8T         T9C      

NOTE: Please keep your comments within reason.Report any abusive comments by clicking the report icon to the left of [reply]. This feature allows both website guests and members to participate. All comments currently are separate from the oBLOGdi-oBLOGda forums but a method is being worked on so comments are interchangable.

MACCA-Central.com
This site requires an HTML 4.0 Transitional compatible browser such the latest Internet Explorer, FireFox
To test your browser for compatibility, click here
Best viewed at least 1024 x 768 screen resolution
All material is presented soley for the purpose of promoting Paul McCartney and his music. No copyright violation is intended or encouraged.
Original material © 1997-2010 Kovy Productions. You may not use any information from this site without permission.
Created by

Mike Kovacich
MACCA-Central logo