It´s really a John text, agree, but I really think that the music is more Paul in 1965. I think he was greatest to melody-songs, the structure of the song, reminds me a bit of Yesterday, Michelle and And I love her, I really imagine that Paul wrote this melody. He said he wrote the whole melody on half an hour, which I find amazing. But the lyrics is maybe the most important in that song I think. I would call it a real Lennon/McCartney compotion, the lyricer and the musiciandsnito wrote:Bluebird wrote:Exactly, therefor I wondering why John said he wrote more of that one than Paul.dsnito wrote:Agreed on you about "Eleanor Rigby", that's VERY Paul...
Yeah, me too...but I still think that "In My Life" is very John, but maybe Paul helped him in some parts...
That´s just my opinion.
I´m just still disagree. It´s match Johns voice, but it´s not difficult to change a song to another key. It could be the song they most dispute who wrote, but I never think that Paul will tell a lie, and he said he wrote that melody. Tell me, when has he lied for a beatles song?
