WHY MACCA IS MY FAVOURITE BEATLE

[amateur]

It's true that Paul had started writing his own songs before John had, but I think it's more the fact that Paul was very gifted musically (I'm not saying John wasn't), but John had more of a raw musical talent and Paul was more technical.

Yes, I AGREE WITH YOU, I MEAN, I REALLY CONSIDER THAT PAUL KNOWS MORE THAN JOHN.. KIND OF...

ANYWAY, I THINKG JOHN IS GOOD, BUT.... NOT A LOT AS PAUL ...

[amateur]

It's true that Paul had started writing his own songs before John had, but I think it's more the fact that Paul was very gifted musically (I'm not saying John wasn't), but John had more of a raw musical talent and Paul was more technical.

Yes, I AGREE WITH YOU, I MEAN, I REALLY CONSIDER THAT PAUL KNOWS MORE THAN JOHN.. KIND OF...

ANYWAY, I THINKG JOHN IS GOOD, BUT.... NOT A LOT AS PAUL ...

[EddieV]

Paul made many of John and Georges songs great by adding backing vocal, bass and sometimes great pianoplaying.

[amateur]

Paul made many of John and Georges songs great by adding backing vocal, bass and sometimes great pianoplaying.

YES...

THE WORST THING IS THAT THEY DIDN'T REALIZE ABOUT IT

[2 of 3]

Paul made many of John and Georges songs great by adding backing vocal, bass and sometimes great pianoplaying.

I'm sure the same can be said going in the other directions too......which is why the 4 of them, are the Beatles.

[EddieV]

Hey watch this

http://livedigital.com/content/5633/u1894

[james1985]

Hey watch this

http://livedigital.com/content/5633/u1894

that was cute!

[admiral_halsey]

However much you love Paul, you gotta love all 4 of em really. It's the Fab Four, COME ON!!

[btls4ever1940]

I have always regarded John as my favorite Beatle b/c he stuck out more during Beatle mania, well to me anyway. It seemed he got into different stuff before the rest of them, plus he was the comical one and seemed to speak for the group. But as time wears on (and after I read Cynthia Lennon's book) I tend to lean more towards Paul b/c he is so generous and he's real. Some people give him crap for writing love songs but if that is all he has in his heart can anyone fault him for that? I don't know if we can compare Paul and John's music b/c John took some time off and he died 25 years ago. In my opinion, George, Paul, and John were all geniuses in their own right. When they broke up they each made totally different music.

[Cor Angais]

I think Paul was always my favorite because his drive and passion for the group was always so prevelent. You can always give him the "cheerleader" title when it came to the group, plus he came up with the "Sgt. Pepper" and "Magical Mystery Tour" concepts while, during this period, John and George especially were so busy with LSD. Plus he was always (and is) charming, clear-minded, showbiz-conscious, and a people-pleaser. If it weren't for Paul, the Beatles probably would have disbanded around '67, I think.