You rather...

by **Grillo** » Mon May 19, 2003 7:31 pm

Which beatle songs do u prefer live instead of studio?

Heres my list: Cant but me love(i dont like the mix very much, pretty weak, the Anthology version with backing vocals is incredible), Shes a woman, This Boy, Babys in Black(same as CBML), Do you want to know a secret(Geoff sings it better live), Chains, You cant do that(Ringo is better in this one).

PS: All my loving from Hollywood Bowl is awesome!!!
Eight days a week live? it would had been great

by **Grillo** » Mon May 19, 2003 7:31 pm

Which beatle songs do u prefer live instead of studio?

Heres my list: Cant but me love(i dont like the mix very much, pretty weak, the Anthology version with backing vocals is incredible), Shes a woman, This Boy, Babys in Black(same as CBML), Do you want to know a secret(Geoff sings it better live), Chains, You cant do that(Ringo is better in this one).

PS: All my loving from Hollywood Bowl is awesome!!!
Eight days a week live? it would had been great

by **Helter Skelter** » Tue May 20, 2003 3:32 am

Ive always prefered the rock songs in live versions.. She´s a woman from hollywood bowl is a faveourite..
But no live version has beaten the studioversion of Long tall sally though[:)]

by **admiralvanderbilt** » Tue May 20, 2003 4:12 am

The Long and Winding Road. Mainly because I don't think any of the recorded versions really do it justice.

by **DylansMrJones** » Tue May 20, 2003 6:37 am

If the STAR CLUB stuff had been recorded properly instead of horribly, I think many of those versions of the familiar Beatles songs and cover tunes would have equalled or surpassed the studio versions. Those Hamburg shows must have been awesome.

by **admiralvanderbilt** » Tue May 20, 2003 7:17 am

quote:Originally posted by DylansMrJones
If the STAR CLUB stuff had been recorded properly ....Those Hamburg shows must have been awesome.

Yup, and a very different sound to the studio sound. Faster, louder etc - early 60s punk / thrash !

by **megs** » Sun May 25, 2003 3:19 pm

hello goodbye
the end
hey jude
sgt. pepper[:D]

by **Brains** » Mon May 26, 2003 3:59 am

quote:Originally posted by admiralvanderbilt
quote:Originally posted by DylansMrJones
If the STAR CLUB stuff had been recorded properly ....Those Hamburg shows must have been awesome.

Yup, and a very different sound to the studio sound. Faster, louder etc - early 60s punk / thrash !

That must have really been something, back then. If you compare the average early 60's music to what the Beatles were playing... It's 'way beyond compare'!

by **Ghavi** » Thu Jun 26, 2003 2:29 pm

Babys in Black !!!
Na songasa...
Even there is not (Cu´ando) its great... 3 voices... lots of bass things and bla bla...
[:o)]

by **theDingle** » Thu Jun 26, 2003 4:02 pm

I'm with you on This Boy, Grillo. John really belts it out.

I also like the live performances from Sweden that appear on Anthology 1, they knock me out. The liner notes in the booklet describe them as exuberant, and exuberant they ARE!

I also think Thank You Girl off Live @ the BBC is done with some added energy.

You rather...

You rather...

You rather...

Who is online