As far as "The washed up WHO", I'm not sure if I agree with that. Their performance at the Concert for NYC was just short of amazing, instrumentally. I know Roger strains, but they blew everyone off of the stage that evening, including a very rusty Macca (who has since redeemed himself SEVERAL times quite nicely, thank-you). Zak did a decent job on the drums, but it was Pete who stole the show. I do know that John was like a 2nd lead guitar with his bass, and will be sorely missed. I don't know what to think about them playing so soon---I know if I was a huge fan, I'd want them to continue, and if JE would've wanted it, why not. I do think that Robert Plant is far past his prime, but I've only seen him a few times, so I can't say about today.